skywayman

New Handgun, .40 or .45?

31 posts in this topic

Hey, the wife just gave me the green light for a new handgun. I am looking for a piece that will be good for carry, plinking, HD, and a hunting sidearm. I am trying to decide between .40 and .45. I'd like the .45 for the additional stopping power, but am drawn to the .40 for its lower ammo costs.I am favoring the Sprinfield Armory XD series.I'd appreciate your thoughts.Mike (skywayman)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mike,One vote for the .40. I have the CZ 75B and use it for plinking, shooting at the range, and as a holster gun when hunting. For the price, it's tough to beat. The ammo prices for the .45 get a little tough.S&SI'm assuming you already have a 9mm...the ammo prices are much easier on the pocketbook.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I would look at a 44Mag revolver. If you are going to be carrying while hunting, it is going to pick up some dirt and stuff. A revolver will go bang much more frequently than a semi under those conditions. And 44 special is a hoot to plink to with. Just my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a Sig P220 in .45 ACP and a S&W Sigma series SW40VE in .40. I love them both. The .45 is in my shoulder holster for hunts. The .40 is my preferred carry for anything else. Plus sometimes my daughter uses my .40 when she is only carrying the 10/22 in case something bigger comes up close. I like the .45 stopping power, but the .40 is a pleasure to shoot. Both sit in my quick access safe load with CorBon ammo with Trijicon night sites. Either one works great. Try them out and see which one you like better.Darren

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well I have a couple of 45s, a 40, a 44 etc.. and IMHO the all steel 45s and the 44 Mag are a pain to carry all day concealed. I used to carry everyday in another job and was issued a 1911A1, they're a lot easier to carry in a duty holster forward of the hipbone than concealed behind it. And any 44 mag light enough for carry is going to smack the heck out of you in recoil and make a lousy plinker unless you shoot 44 specials.My new carry gun is a polymer framed 4" 40 cal and I'm going to add a 3" version to that to make it even easier to carry. It's a nice plinker and self defense round but not a hunter. Just about any gun light and small enough to carry concealed is usually too light and short to hunt well. I don't think that there is one caliber or configuration that will meet all the requirements on your list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think I would look at a 44Mag revolver. If you are going to be carrying while hunting, it is going to pick up some dirt and stuff. A revolver will go bang much more frequently than a semi under those conditions. And 44 special is a hoot to plink to with. Just my opinion.
Ditto. Another choice might be a S&W 686 .357 mag W/ 4" barrel. Easy to carry and download to 38's for plinking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the input so far. Good food for thought.

I'm assuming you already have a 9mm...the ammo prices are much easier on the pocketbook.
Actually, I don't have a 9mm. I was seriously considering 9mm for this purchase, but all my redneck and law enforcement friends would make fun of me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ditto. Another choice might be a S&W 686 .357 mag W/ 4" barrel. Easy to carry and download to 38's for plinking.
And thinking about this a little more, what about one of Rugers Blackhawk single action revolvers with the xtra cylinder. I have one in 45 Colt with an xtra cylinder for 45 ACP. Another is in 357 mag with a xtra 9mm cylinder.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As I fondle my gold cup frame/remington slide/bomar sights/national match barrel 1911, I am forced to cry out, "FORTY FIVE". But only becaus I know it's best for you. :D:blink::D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Actually, I don't have a 9mm. I was seriously considering 9mm for this purchase, but all my redneck and law enforcement friends would make fun of me.
skyway,That's weird...when I think of Paradise I don't think of rednecks. :D:blink::D S&S

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

.45 or 44 mag for hunting! You cannot beat the stopping power of a .45, as much as a .40 lover would like to think so. I own 1 of every caliber and I don't care for my .40 at all (It's for sale!) :blink: What is most important is how each gun feels in your hand and how you shoot with it. Go to an indoor range and rent 1 of each.. I love my Sig P220 and my S/W .44 mag 6inch. Good luck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You guys are awesome. I've done some range time and borrowed a variety of guns and calibers.Good news is there is a gun show in Chico this weekend. We'll see how it turns out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Springfield XD is an over-advertised over-priced inferior copy of a Glock. I shot one of the 45's. It's accurate, light, no malfunctions. Same as a Glock. The trigger is exactly the same as a Glock. The gun feels just like a Glock. My buddy's new XD rusted on the slide though. When's the last time you heard of a Glock rusting? the XD is a Glock with some slight modifications to the appearance. and a lesser finish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have to agree with SN here, i did not want to say anything but, the XD is a cheap knock off of a Glock and when shot side by side the only comparison that can be made is they shoot they same ammo. my brother is getting ready to sell his 40 XD to get a glock after shooting mine. the Glock just handle better acording to us. but thats only M.H.O.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The Springfield XD is an over-advertised over-priced inferior copy of a Glock.
Now that we're being completely open and honest...and not worrying about stepping on toes or egos...I completely agree with Stiff Neck. The XD is a marketing baby and that's about it.Some people think the same thing about the difference between a Taurus and a S&W.S&S

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are stuck on a semi-auto for use while hunting a Glock model 20 in 10mm should fit the bill nicely. More juice than the 40 S&W and the 45 ACP. And it should impress your redneck and LEO buddies :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well the Chico gun show was disappointing. Even though this thread was titled "New Handgun, .40 or .45," I have decided to go with the Springfield Armory XD-9 Subcompact. Now I just need to wait for the irritating 10-day waiting period to end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, let's see. Probably the main factors were feel and reliability. The grip angle and size really fits me well. I like the grip safety. Reviews on the gun show it be a very worthy and reliable piece. When I shot it at my local range, I found it be a great natural point and shoot. I like some of the extras such as the loaded chamber and striker status indicator. What can I say, those Croatians know how to build a nice gun and Springfield has a great reputation for backing it up with service. The price means that I get more gun for my money than a Glock. I actually like its appearance too--a lot of folks say it's an ugly gun, I think it just looks like a serious piece of metal and polymer. CA waiting period--The longest 10 days of your life. (8 days to go)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
B) Good choice. I have a Glock 21(.45) and a 22(.40) and love both of them. I have shot the 9mm XD and it is a fun gun. I think the concealed carry factor was probably what led you to the 9mm, don't let anyone tell you that it won't stop anything. A .45 is far superior to the 9mm in power but the 9mm is lighter and cheaper to shoot :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You got it, especially the cheaper to shoot. IF I can shoot it more, it will be a better carry gun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now