Camoghost

.22 or .25 Marauder ??

49 posts in this topic

I'm getting ready to pull the trigger on a new Marauder (no pun).. I have read some reviews on Pyramyd Air that the .25 cal is more accurate than the .22 cal? Can anyone guide me in the right diection? The gun will be used for hunting small game and punching holes in paper. Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well you will have less selection of ammo in .25 rather than .22. My Mrod is very accurate, shooting barracudas 21.14grain 30+ fpe. I don't have a .25 Mrod to compare, But my guess is that it can just shoot longer distance....not more accurateBut the .22 can shoot 100 yards, who really needs more?Lets ask VarmintAir...He has both.....,probably shootin it right now ;)P.s. you said you would plink/hunt....Then yeah I would go .22 enough power for hunting medium sized game, Ammo is cheaper, and more selection. .25 caliber in my opinion is more for serious Hunting/hunters...not casual plinkingthey are getting almost 60fpe turned up to the max, that's crazy. enough to hunt hogs,coyotes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My suggestion would be to consider what game you would hunt with the .25....I have found the .22 cal to be adequate for most all small game.MAC 1 Discovery .22..906 FPS using JSB 14.3 Gr..Dominator 1250 (HPA) .22..940 FPS using JSB 15.8 Gr..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been the proud owner of my Mac1 .25 cal Marauder for all of about 36 hours. This is my first .25 cal airgun, and at this point I've got all of 20 rounds down the barrel. I have only been able to shoot it at 20 yards indoors. I'm thrilled with the way it's shooting so far, but I won't be able to shoot it at 50/55 yards until I can get into the forest, and most of the roads are still impassable from the heavy winter snows.If it were me, and I was only going to have one or the other, I would choose the .22. It has more than enough power to take pretty much all of the small game and varmints that are legal, and ethical airgun targets. Accuracy is superb, and pellet selection is very good.I like trying new stuff, so I thought I would give a .25 a go, but it wouldn't be my first choice, nor would it be the one gun I would keep if it ever came down to that. For me, it's just an addition to the arsenal of air toys that I already have, and something interesting and new to play with. Here's a couple of pics of the first three groups I shot from the gun while testing the 31 grain Kodiak's for accuracy. These are at 20 yards indoors. Each group's 8 shots, thats one full mag.I've got some 25 grain .25 cal JSB's and the new 27 grain Benjamins inbound, and will be testing those in the near future. Those are Advil tablets in the picture for size perspective. P4230006.jpgP4230007.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cliff your .25 Maurader may be just the ticket for Prarrie Dog hunting...be interesting to see results of your hunts on those critters...long range,wind,etc..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Those are very nice groups Cliff. I think you have a real winner there. I also agree with your reasoning on why a .22cal would be a better all around choice. But being that you have an excellent arsenal of airguns it is a great addition. Thanks for showing us what it can do so far. When you get some chronograph readings please let us know.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Cliff your .25 Maurader may be just the ticket for Prarrie Dog hunting...be interesting to see results of your hunts on those critters...long range,wind,etc..
You know it's kind of funny, because hunting these prairie dogs is what really got me to thinking seriously about adding a .25 to the battery. Somedays I spend as much time chasing my hat in the wind as I do hunting. Well, maybe not quite that bad, but you get the idea. The faster the wind blows, the closer I need to get for a reasonable chance at a killing shot. Sometimes that's only 50/55 yards. The wind causes the pellets to turn into curve balls and sliders. When possible, I try and keep it at my back, or in my face, but that doesn't always work out either. I'm thinking that a .25 cal shooting a 27 to 31 grain pellet at around 900 fps would buck the wind better and let me push those ranges back out to 65/70 yards. Come June, when prairie dog season opens here, I'll get a chance to see if a .25 makes any real difference. Should be fun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Those are very nice groups Cliff. I think you have a real winner there. I also agree with your reasoning on why a .22cal would be a better all around choice. But being that you have an excellent arsenal of airguns it is a great addition. Thanks for showing us what it can do so far. When you get some chronograph readings please let us know.
I think we're only about a week or so away from getting into the forest around here. I'll get some 50/55 yard groups then. I'll be doing some chrono work as soon as the other pellets get here, and that should be some time next week. My California squirrel hunting trip has been rained out twice now, so that may not happen this year. The local prairie dogs will be expected to pick up the slack. :roflmao3[1]:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd go for the .25. Accurate and better for 'Coon/Possum sized game. And the selection of ammo is improving. Also with the proper .25 pellet bucks the wind better, and has more fpe on your distant shots. Also squirrels are the toughest most stubborn little devils I"ve ever shot. The .25 hits harder and punches a bigger hole/larger wound cavity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've shot several raccoons and possum along with close to 100 skunks using my FX Monsoon in .22cal and they don't get away. So a .22 is plenty really.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You know it's kind of funny, because hunting these prairie dogs is what really got me to thinking seriously about adding a .25 to the battery. Somedays I spend as much time chasing my hat in the wind as I do hunting. Well, maybe not quite that bad, but you get the idea. The faster the wind blows, the closer I need to get for a reasonable chance at a killing shot. Sometimes that's only 50/55 yards. The wind causes the pellets to turn into curve balls and sliders. When possible, I try and keep it at my back, or in my face, but that doesn't always work out either. I'm thinking that a .25 cal shooting a 27 to 31 grain pellet at around 900 fps would buck the wind better and let me push those ranges back out to 65/70 yards. Come June, when prairie dog season opens here, I'll get a chance to see if a .25 makes any real difference. Should be fun.
Cliff I think you're going to have a lot of fun with the .25. With the magic you've displayed here an on other sites with your .22's, I believe the .25 would extend that range. I am absolutely confidant that the .25 in a relatively heavy pellet, 31+, bucks the wind better than most if not all .22's. Ofcourse density has a lot to do with it. I wouldn't recommend using a 43g EJ as your go-to lead, because of drop, but it's amazing in the wind. 31g H&N seem to be very uniform and/or even the softer leaded 35g EJ tears them up at distance, even sans a headshot."....27 to 31 grain pellet at around 900 fps would buck the wind better and let me push thos ranges back out to 65/70 yards."IMHO with your markmanship, it won't be long before that range, sans wind, using a .25, will be extended by 10-15 yards. Find your go-to pellet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'm thinking that a .25 cal shooting a 27 to 31 grain pellet at around 900 fps would buck the wind better and let me push those ranges back out to 65/70 yards. Come June, when prairie dog season opens here, I'll get a chance to see if a .25 makes any real difference. Should be fun.
Don't forget that to buck wind, flatten trajectory and have a maximum impact velocity you need a good ballistic coefficient. Unfortunately, the 27 - 31 gr .25 pellets have a BC of .022 or .023, Not as good as several of the .22 pellets. The JSB Exact, a 15.74 gr .22 pellet has a .032 BC, while the .22 Kodiak and the .22 Crow Magnum have .035 BC. The BC king of both the .25 and the .22 world seems to be the Eun Jin .22 caliber, 29 grain pellet with a BC of .047. Of course these BC's are puny compared to the powder gun world but, the further you stretch the range the more difference they make.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Don't forget that to buck wind, flatten trajectory and have a maximum impact velocity you need a good ballistic coefficient. Unfortunately, the 27 - 31 gr .25 pellets have a BC of .022 or .023, Not as good as several of the .22 pellets. The JSB Exact, a 15.74 gr .22 pellet has a .032 BC, while the .22 Kodiak and the .22 Crow Magnum have .035 BC. The BC king of both the .25 and the .22 world seems to be the Eun Jin .22 caliber, 29 grain pellet with a BC of .047. Of course these BC's are puny compared to the powder gun world but, the further you stretch the range the more difference they make.
I think some of the numbers you have are a bit off. Here's the chart that I get my info from. It shows the BC for the 31 grain .25 cal Kodiak to be .037, the 21 grain .22 Kodiak is shown to be .036, and the .22 Crow Mag to be .022.http://www.airgunforum.co.uk/forums/airgun...ts-bc-info.html

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Marino....LoL @ shoooting squirrels with .25 cals, thats funny stuff. kinda overkill
I've read where guys have shot them with .22 rimfires and they still take off. I've hit them with .25 43g EJ's clean thru, mid-section, and they still run off. I don't believe it's overkill. I'd use a .22 rimfre in my backyard if it were legal. Most people that have experience shooting squirrels know how tough they are pound per pound.BTW, none of the squirrels on property from where I shoot off my back porch reside within 50 yards. They're out there from about 50-140. I don't go after the 50 or 60 yard squirrels like I did last season. I want this season to last a bit. 31g H&N at 950 fps was able to handle the unfortunate squirrel at a lazered 142 yrds. with a 2 dot holdover, and about a 20% downgrage. A 20% larger wound channel makes a difference.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think some of the numbers you have are a bit off. Here's the chart that I get my info from. It shows the BC for the 31 grain .25 cal Kodiak to be .037, the 21 grain .22 Kodiak is shown to be .036, and the .22 Crow Mag to be .022.http://www.airgunforum.co.uk/forums/airgun...ts-bc-info.html
Well here is the chart I used, from Straight Shooters. Straight Shooters Ballistics Chart I believe they test and develop their own data, rather than inviting people to send in ballistic coefficient data. But it is interesting to have multiple data sources.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well here is the chart I used, from Straight Shooters. Straight Shooters Ballistics Chart I believe they test and develop their own data, rather than inviting people to send in ballistic coefficient data. But it is interesting to have multiple data sources.
Here's another list of BC's that you might find handy on occasion. http://www.airgunexpo.com/airgundb/pellet.cfm

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Today with some friends...82 yards..Disco .22...funshootpinevalley005.jpgThe rifle..note can was at pine tree in background just left of barrel in this pic...funshootpinevalley004.jpgI might add, both the other guys hit cans at 80 yards with .177 cal 12 FPE rifles...Do not under-estimate range of these air rifles...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think anyone is underestimating what a .177 can do at 80 yards with little to no wind. But there's a big diffeence in wound channel and fpe, and a heavier pellet bucks the wind better than a smaller one. Move that can to 150 yards. :-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Here's another list of BC's that you might find handy on occasion. http://www.airgunexpo.com/airgundb/pellet.cfm
Thanks, it's always good to have another reference list. Now if I can just find a source for the Beeman Crow Magnum 26.2 gr, .25 caliber, the ones with the .230 BC. With those and a 1001 fps muzzle velocity you could put 50 fpe on a critter at 100 yds. That would be 929 fps at 100 yds. It would have a 10 MPH wind drift of 2.1". Unfortunately that BC was undoubtedly a typo. :two-cents: With the .022 BC from Straight Shooters the 100 yd data is 15 fpe and 512 fps the 10 MPH wind drift would be 23.2".With the .011 BC from Andy in the UK the 100 yd data is 4 fpe and 266 fps the 10 MPH wind drift would be 58.2".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW! Thank you guys so much for all of the info!! I didn't get a chance to sign in all weekend and I'm amazed at all the good info that was waiting for me. Okay, I'm going .22 for several reasons.. Now I have a new question: Mac1 .22 Marauder or Mac1 Disco?Thanks again everyone!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Marauder is Very pellet picky out of the box, and seems to only like crosman made pellets. You'll need High mount rings to clear the magazine,3-9x40,4-12x40,4-16x40....are all good scope sizes for this gun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now