Magic Chicken

17 HMR Rifle Suggestions

36 posts in this topic

Aside from looking for the best long range varmint caliber, I'm also looking to get a 17 HMR. As far as I've read, it has the best ballistics and range of the rimfire calibers. My 10/22 is fun, but I want more power out of a rimfire. :lol: I was looking at a Savage and a Marlin today, but I hate the Accu-Trigger and the action on the Marlin felt kinda rough and cheap. Granted these were only $220 rifles and there is definitely room for improvement with aftermarket parts.So what do you all like in 17 HMR? Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Aside from looking for the best long range varmint caliber, I'm also looking to get a 17 HMR. As far as I've read, it has the best ballistics and range of the rimfire calibers. My 10/22 is fun, but I want more power out of a rimfire. :lol: I was looking at a Savage and a Marlin today, but I hate the Accu-Trigger and the action on the Marlin felt kinda rough and cheap. Granted these were only $220 rifles and there is definitely room for improvement with aftermarket parts.So what do you all like in 17 HMR? Thanks!
I like the looks of the Ruger bolt gun and the CZ 452. Since I'm left handed I bought the only one that came in lefty, the Savage 93 but I have a left handed CZ 22 lr now also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What's your price range, and what's the MOST important thing to you, accuracy or looks? In the rimfire world, you can't have both. :)You could buy a used pre-Accutrigger Savage, and then get an aftermarket trigger for it. A new Marlin with an aftermarket trigger would rock. A new Savage is just as good but you don't like the Accutrigger. Those are your inexpensive options. They shoot fantastic, but fit and finish is a bit lacking. Rugers look sweet but there's a lot of reports that they don't shoot well. CZ is good looking and most of them shoot good too. Anschutz are nice too. There's always a Cooper if you've got the cash, but I doubt they shoot well enough to justify the price considering how well a cheap ol' Savage/Marlin shoots. Those are your pricey options. They're easy on the eyes. I say, get the new Savage and get used to the Accutrigger.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What's your price range, and what's the MOST important thing to you, accuracy or looks? In the rimfire world, you can't have both. :lol:
I'm not too worried about the looks as long as it's accurate, the looks can always be improved cheaper than accuracy.If price wasn't an option, I'd get the $900 Volquartsen with carbon fiber barrel and muzzle brake. But that's kind of insane for a rimfire in my opinion even if it is a semi-auto 17 HMR.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looks like a CZ fits your bill, it's a nice looking rifle. It's about twice the price of a Savage or Marlin, but less than a Ruger. And the CZ will likely shoot middle-of-the-pack, better than a Ruger but probably not as well as a Savage or Marlin. Hurry up and buy it so you can take pics and post range reports. Meanwhile, I'm still trying to talk my father-in-law out of buying a Ruger 17HMR. He's in love with the looks of it, and he knows it won't shoot as good as my cheapie Marlin. But the whole reason he wants a 17HMR is because of the amazing accuracy he experienced with my Marlin, he can't stop talking about it. Yet he's going to purchase the least accurate brand out there... I can't talk him out of it... :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Marlin, Savage or CZ. Cz more $ but nice wood, fit, finish, trigger, etc. and very accurate. Stay away from the plastic stocks if possible. The SSS trigger on the old Savage or the RB trigger fixes that on the Savage and Marlin. There are also some aftermarket stocks out that help in the pretty dept. Don't underscope it.JMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone have an opinion on the T/C G2 Contender in 17 HMR? If anyone has one, how hard are the barrel changes? Sounds like a cool concept to have virtually a new gun in 12 different calibers for $200-250 each.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ben, my Ruger shoots like a lazer gun... I guess I got lucky? I will say though, that the bolt can be smoother, a bit rough.... I'd go with the VQ semi auto. Only because when I shoot with Capitol, he'll clean out an area faster before I can even rack the bolt :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't like the trigger safety part of the Accu-Trigger. It feels like pulling 2 triggers to me. But I guess I'm weird.Is it possible to rebarrel a 10/22 to make it a 17 HMR?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Is it possible to rebarrel a 10/22 to make it a 17 HMR?
You can rebarrel a .22mag but no you can't change the lowly 10/22LR. The action can't take the abuse of the mag cartridge hammering it.I could never figure the muzzle brakes on a .17HMR I mean they look cool and all. But do you really need one for that awesome recoil? :lol: Larger centerfires I can see it. But then anyone shooting with you will hate you for the noise and anything you kick up in their face. :) Sorry I read the wrong post earlier about left handed. But the Ansch?tz .17HMR would be my choice for the ultimate in accuracy in a bolt gun. Joel's Ruger is a specially made gun show him a picture Joel.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Yes, if you have a 10/22 mag and not the more common 10/22 LR receiver.
I beat you to the punch. :):lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
looks and accuracy.....dont make me put a pic of the VQ 17HMR rifle here too, John :P
Explain why they have that muzzle brake on there would you? :lol: I mean the recoil must be horrendous right? ;):) I'll reach into my bag of famous quotes for you.
You like sissy girl!
Ace Ventura - When Nature Calls. B):P Sorry I couldn't help myself. :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm never shy showing off pics :)79646243.jpgRuger X-17 17HMRPANA0053.jpgRuger 10/22 converted with a Boyd's conversion kit to shoot 17HM2 (necked down 22lr). I just love this gun and slowly being accepted in the CPC ;)PANA0051.jpgVQ 22lr rifle with muzzle brake just for John... This really does not need a brake. It does look cool though, but with the weight and the brake, the rifle doesn't move at all when on the bench. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
VQ 22lr rifle with muzzle brake just for John... This really does not need a brake. It does look cool though, but with the weight and the brake, the rifle doesn't move at all when on the bench. ;)
Nice guns. :P The reason I wanted you to post that picture of your Ruger X-17 is it isn't your standard Ruger. :lol: I don't think it would move without the brake. :):P At least my 10/22 doesn't. B)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hey, I have a brake on my 10/22. It does make a difference. :lol: I think. Well, at least it looks cool.
Yeah! I get the looks cool part. B)Not picking on you capitol If I spent that much money I'd want bitchin holes drilled in my barrel too. :) I mean look at the weight and blast reduction! B) :lol:I know I'm just jealous I don't have holes in my head I mean barrel too. ;)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't even think VQ offers their barrels without brakes? I'm sure some of their barrels do, but the fluted ones almost all come with brakes...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I don't even think VQ offers their barrels without brakes? I'm sure some of their barrels do, but the fluted ones almost all come with brakes...
Their Standard model comes without the brake.standard.jpgI'm just giving everyone a hard time about the brakes. They look neat and I'd have one on mine if they came that way. Maybe I'll head out to the shop and fire up the drill press. Then again maybe I better not. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea John You've been talking about it for a year or more. Dive in the water's fine. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW those Volquartsen rifles are sure nice I like the snake fluted model they are just to expensive for me at this time. I will just buy the poor man gun a savage ..... :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Anyone have an opinion on the T/C G2 Contender in 17 HMR? If anyone has one, how hard are the barrel changes? Sounds like a cool concept to have virtually a new gun in 12 different calibers for $200-250 each.
It is cool! It is addicting also. I have a 10" Bullberry and a 16.5" TC 17 HMR barrels for my old style Contenders and a 14" HM2 barrel also. Barrel changes are about a minute with either style. You're not limited to 12 calibers by anything except your wallet. I've taken PD out to 280 yds with the carbine.Then there are the four centerfire 17 barrels. :lol: Well you get the idea. :lol: A17Shooter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I sure got a bunch of them. But the part that really gripes me is you pay a pretty fair price for a good barrel. Then you have to buy a scope for each one. I'm working on a flat top rail like on my AR's so I can get a LaRue mount and swap one or two scopes around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just use a Weaver 92a base and Weaver Rings. Not real pretty but, you can swap the scopes quickly and the zero is usually pretty close. And, it is cost effective.A17Shooter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now